Greater Iowa Reef Society
Register  |  Login
Reef Tank Supply
 
You are here :- Community >> Discussion Forums
Unanswered Active Topics Forums Search
Forums > Public Forums > General (Hobby Related)
HOB Fiulter or no filter...
Last Post 08/15/2008 08:00 PM by jtesdall. 2 Replies.
AddThis - Bookmarking and Sharing ButtonPrinter Friendly
Sort:
PrevPrev NextNext
You are not authorized to post a reply.
AuthorMessages
Des Moines, Iowa
Average
Posts/Points: 135/203
Avatar


--
08/14/2008 09:54 PM  

EDTI:  sorry about the spelling in the title, can't fix it now so I will just sit here and look silly.Â


Yet another question from a fairly new guy....Â

I have read on other forums of some not using any filter(s) at all, that said I am still 'getting started' all I have right now is a Marineland 330 that I am currently using, I would guess the bio wheels really don't provide much of an advantage since my tank is already full of live rock, would that be correct?  Also is there any advantage of NOT using the filter OR using it for a short time once a day OR just leave it as is and run it 24/7? I am just trying to gain as much knowledge as I can before I expand to something larger.

Advanced Member
Posts/Points: 588/638
Avatar


--
08/15/2008 12:08 AM  
I would gut the filter and just throw a bag of activated carbon and a bag of phosphate remover in it.
Boone Iowa
Advanced Member
Posts/Points: 650/732
Avatar
GIRS Member


--
08/15/2008 08:00 PM  
To expand on Travis's advice which I agree with: Reef Tanks use almost all natural filtration. Most people will use a filter sock on the return but change it at least weekly. The problem with any mechanical filtration is detrius gets trapped and turns into a nitrate factory. We have enough problems with nitrate in our tanks without adding that. Once your tank is well established it will stay amazingly clear. So just use that filter for chemical media like Travis mentioned or for short durations to polish a new tank or when something has been stirred up. Hope this helps.
Joel Tesdall
Size doesn't matter - it's the quality of the reef that counts.
You are not authorized to post a reply.
Forums > Public Forums > General (Hobby Related)

Active Forums 4.1
You must be logged in to use this module.
Copyright 2007, Greater Iowa Reef Society   ::  Greater Iowa Reef Society  ::  Privacy Statement  ::  Terms Of Use